Choosing the right brawler lineup can make or break your game in Brawl Stars. Whether you're aiming for victory in Brawl Ball, Gem Grab, or Showdown, understanding which brawlers excel and which ones might hold you back is crucial. Here's a comprehensive look at the top five best and worst brawlers you should consider for your lineup.

Top 5 Best Brawlers

1. Piper

Piper stands out as one of the most versatile and powerful brawlers in the game. Her long-range attacks and high damage output make her a formidable opponent in any mode. In Gem Grab or Siege, Piper can control key areas with her precision shots, while in Showdown, her ability to eliminate enemies from a distance gives her a strategic advantage. Her super ability, Super: Peacekeeper, allows her to snipe enemies from afar, providing excellent map control and cover.

Strategy Tips: Use Piper's range to your advantage by staying on the outskirts of the battlefield. Upgrade her to increase damage and range, making her even more lethal. Pair Piper with a tanky brawler like Frank or Bull to distract enemies while she picks them off from a distance.

2. Shelly

Shelly is a reliable choice for any lineup, thanks to her balanced abilities and versatility. Her shotgun attacks are effective at close to medium range, allowing her to deal significant damage to multiple enemies. In game modes like Heist or Brawl Ball, Shelly can both defend and attack objectives efficiently.

Strategy Tips: Use Shelly's Super: Super Shell to stun and damage multiple enemies, giving your team the upper hand in fights. Enhance her range and damage through upgrades to maximize her effectiveness in both offense and defense. Combining Shelly with a support brawler like Pam can create a strong frontline.

3. Spike

Spike brings a unique blend of area control and damage over time to the table. His attacks can cover a wide area, making it difficult for opponents to maneuver without taking damage. In modes like Bounty or Hot Zone, Spike can zone enemies effectively and control key areas of the map.

Strategy Tips: Utilize Spike's Super: Stick Around to crowd control and damage groups of enemies. Combine Spike with brawlers that can protect him while he sets up his traps. Upgrading Spike increases his damage and the effectiveness of his area control, making him a valuable asset in any team.

4. Pam

Pam is the ultimate support brawler, healing teammates and providing consistent damage output. Her super, Super: Mama's Hug, heals allies while dealing damage to enemies, making her indispensable in clutch situations. In modes like Siege or Heist, Pam can sustain your team through prolonged engagements.

Strategy Tips: Position Pam in the backline to maximize her healing capabilities while staying protected from enemy attacks. Upgrade her healing power and damage to enhance her support role. Pair Pam with durable brawlers like Bull or Frank who can hold the frontline while she maintains team health.

5. Byron

Byron offers a unique combination of healing and damage, making him a versatile choice in various game modes. His attacks deal damage upfront and provide healing over time, which can turn the tide of battles in your favor. In Gem Grab or Siege, Byron can sustain your team while contributing to offense.

Strategy Tips: Leverage Byron's dual capabilities by positioning him to both heal allies and target enemies. Upgrade his attack and healing abilities to enhance his versatility. Combining Byron with aggressive brawlers like Rico or Colt can create a balanced and formidable team.

Top 5 Worst Brawlers

1. Dynamike

Dynamike’s explosive attacks can be a double-edged sword. While his bombs deal significant damage, his short range and delay in attack can make him vulnerable in fast-paced situations. His super, Super: Big Bomb, is powerful but requires precise timing and placement to be effective.

Strategy Tips: If you choose to use Dynamike, focus on controlling choke points and using his bombs to disrupt enemy movements. However, be cautious of his positioning as he is susceptible to quick flankers. Consider upgrading his range and damage to mitigate some of his vulnerabilities.

2. Larry & Lawry

Larry and Lawry, as a duo, can be challenging to manage effectively. Their synergy is heavily reliant on teamwork, and in solo play, they might not perform optimally. Their synchronized attacks can sometimes leave gaps in their defense, making them exploitable by skilled opponents.

Strategy Tips: Use Larry and Lawry in coordinated team play where their combined abilities can shine. Focus on communication and strategic positioning to maximize their synergy. Upgrading their joint abilities can help bridge the gaps in their defense and improve their overall performance.

3. Mortis

Mortis’s quick movements and melee attacks make him a tricky brawler, but his role as a "ball hog" in modes like Brawl Ball can be detrimental to team objectives. His low hit points and reliance on close combat can make him vulnerable against ranged brawlers.

Strategy Tips: Use Mortis to lure enemies and disrupt their formations, but avoid holding onto the ball for too long. Upgrade his speed and damage to enhance his mobility and combat effectiveness. Pair Mortis with support brawlers who can provide backup during his aggressive plays.

4. Frank

Frank’s high health and melee damage can make him a solid frontline brawler, but his lack of range and focus on close combat can limit his versatility. In modes that require map control and strategic positioning, Frank might struggle to contribute effectively.

Strategy Tips: Deploy Frank in game modes where holding the frontline is crucial, such as Gem Grab or Siege. Upgrade his health and melee damage to make him a more effective tank. Combining Frank with ranged attackers can help balance his close-range limitations.

5. Colette

Colette’s ability to deal damage based on the enemy's health makes her a situational brawler. While powerful against high-health targets, she may underperform in scenarios where opponents have lower health. Her super, Super: Soul Reaper, can be game-changing but requires precise execution.

Strategy Tips: Use Colette in matches where you expect to face high-health brawlers or in modes where sustained damage is beneficial. Upgrade her attack and Super to maximize her effectiveness against tougher opponents. Pair Colette with brawlers that can help her survive longer in battles, enhancing her damage potential.

Honorable Mentions

Crow

Crow is a high-mobility brawler with poisoning attacks that deal damage over time. While he can be effective in harassing enemies and controlling areas, his low health makes him vulnerable to burst damage. His super, Super: Toxic Trail, allows him to place poison mines that can disrupt enemy movements.

Strategy Tips: Utilize Crow's speed to dart in and out of combat, applying poison to as many enemies as possible. Upgrade his attack speed and poison duration to increase his harassment potential. Combine Crow with brawlers who can provide support or cover to offset his low durability.

Buzz Lightyear

Buzz Lightyear’s futuristic gadgets and ranged attacks offer unique advantages, but his complexity can be a barrier for some players. Mastering his abilities requires practice and precision, and in the heat of battle, his advanced mechanics can be challenging to execute effectively.

Strategy Tips: Invest time in mastering Buzz Lightyear’s gadgets and supers to fully utilize his potential. Upgrade his range and gadget effectiveness to enhance his battlefield control. Pair Buzz Lightyear with strategic brawlers who can help cover his weaknesses and amplify his strengths.

Final Thoughts

Building a successful brawler lineup in Brawl Stars requires a balance of offense, defense, and support. While the brawlers listed as the best can significantly enhance your team’s performance, understanding the limitations of the weaker brawlers can help you avoid costly mistakes. Always consider the specific game mode and your team's overall strategy when selecting your brawlers.

Experiment with different combinations and stay updated with the latest balance changes to keep your lineup competitive. With the right approach and strategic planning, you can dominate the arena and lead your team to victory.